Norma Gay

norma gay.jpgWe all know that Kathy Griffin loves the gay community, but if there was any question about that, it was answered on last night’s episode of My Life on the D-List. Kathy decided that in order to fulfill her quest to make it to the A-List, she needed to become an activist, and what better way to do that than to protest Prop 8? Well, we can debate that, but her heart is in the right place. In any event, there were a few segments during the episode that resonated with me, so I wanted to discuss them here. (btw, I realize the reference may be a bit dated for this audience, but this entry title and Kathy's sign are references to the 1979 movie Norma Rae starring Sally Field).

First, and perhaps least insightful of my observations (though I don’t necessarily claim that any are particularly sage), I was surprised to hear one woman with whom Kathy spoke while she was canvassing against Prop 8 say something along the lines of, “I have no problem with gay relationships. They can have unions, which gives them the same rights as marriage.” Right? WRONG. Kathy, fortunately, was armed with the famous factoid that marriage provides over 1,000 federal benefits that civil unions do not. This made me wonder, though, how many people have this sort of misinformation? And if they had the correct information, would it have changed their votes? What a lovely illustration of the need to educate the public, no?

During another segment of last night’s episode, Kathy took a group of queer youth to a protest in Sacramento, CA. At the rally, a gay couple spoke about their quandary with medical insurance. One partner had a disability that prevented him from working full-time, and thus prevented him from having medical insurance. The other partner, who worked full-time, had medical insurance, but his union would not allow his partner to be covered as it would with a married opposite-sex couple. They used this as an argument for same-sex marriage. Yes, that’s all well and good. But I don’t see it that way. I see it as a poignant illustration of the inequality of marriage as a social institution and the shortfall of our government in providing healthcare for its citizens. If the disabled partner were single, he still would not have health coverage. Marriage should not be a means of achieving equality, especially in healthcare. Single people should not be taxed more heavily or be laden with any of the other penalties one incurs for not being married. Their story not only shows how society discriminates against single people (hetero or homo), but also the pressing need for universal healthcare in the United States.

Finally, and perhaps most relevant to this blog site, throughout the show Kathy was with a group of queer youths. What struck me about this group was that when Kathy mentioned Matthew Shepard, many stared back with a blank expression. Are you kidding me?! These kids couldn’t have been much younger than I am, and they didn’t know who Matthew Shepard was?

Which brings me to my real question – are queer youths today losing touch with why the gay rights movement began and why it must continue? How many queers in their teens or twenties would know what Stonewall was? I see a lot of complacency in queer youth today, and to be quite honest, it’s upsetting. They (me included) have grown up in a relatively accepting world -- much more so than those who started the gay rights movement in 1969 anyway – and it has desensitized many to the inequalities that still exist for so much of our population. I applaud those who are involved in the queer community, but we need more. This movement has to be fueled by younger queers. The Stonewall generation started it, but it is up to us to keep it going.

6 comments

Stefan Vogler wrote 2 years 22 weeks ago

Yes, HIV is a horrible

Yes, HIV is a horrible disease that is crippling some parts of Africa. But I think if you do a little research, you will see that HIV/AIDS affects the entire population in Africa, in particular, the heterosexual population. HIV/AIDS is by no means a "gay disease" as some like to claim.

And though I have not read extensively about Caster Semenya, I couldn't care less what a "gender" test says about her.

Anonymous wrote 2 years 24 weeks ago

Me, personally I am not in

Me, personally I am not in favor with same-sex marriage. As I read lot of news I can see that this brought horrible plague to the society. HIV now is pandemic in Africa and present all over the world. According to the study, this is caused of marriages that seems to be lacking of respect which commonly leads to immorality. Blood work, invasive probing, the works – it would be less invasive and painful to get auto financing than to conclusively prove Caster Semenya is a female, according to athletic organization standards.

Kellen Bolt wrote 2 years 27 weeks ago

I wish I would have been able

I wish I would have been able to watch last night's episode, it's the one I've been looking forward to all season. I'm wondering, if you feel that the reason for little attention being paid to queer youth issues stems from the over promotion of same sex marriage? I feel that if you ask a lot of people (queers & non queers) what the biggest issue facing the queer community a lot of them would say marriage.

So, perhaps you might not be able to answer this, but I think it's something interesting to consider. How can we make other queer issues as attractive as marriage?

Stefan Vogler wrote 2 years 27 weeks ago

re: queer youth

I completely agree with you, Rachel. We don't have "crisis" to deal with or a galvanizing event, which makes our generation a bit different than our predecessors. And I agree with your thoughts on the mainstream movement. Sadly, as you point out, without any attention from the mainstream, queer youth issues tend to wither. That is why I call on queer youths to become more vocal, more involved, etc. If you cause enough commotion, the mainstream will take notice. As they say, the squeaky wheel gets the oil.

Rachel Gadd-Nelson wrote 2 years 27 weeks ago

Cont'd

And one more thing to add, I forgot to mention: I definitely don't think that all the blame, for lack of a better term, is on the older queer community. You are totally correct in saying that it is up to young queers to keep this going. Queer youth should get involved in their community (and not just the queer community!), they should start GSAs, work with and/or fight their administration to make sure sexual orientation and gender identity are added in their school's non-discrimination policy, and work for whatever cause they identify with! But I don't think it should be expected for us to follow in the mainstream queer movement's footsteps when they have not supported us. We want them to be invested in our causes as well! And if they won't be, well, they shouldn't be surprised if we go and do our own thing! :)

Rachel Gadd-Nelson wrote 2 years 27 weeks ago

Queer Youth

Hey, Stefan! Lovely blog!

Now, I haven't seen this episode, though I would LOVE to, it sounds like it was really good. I'd like to comment, though, on your statement on the complacency of queer youth. I think that is only part of the problem. I think a major contributing factor is that the adult queer community has let our youth down over the years. For example, there are many youth that aren't even aware of who Lawrence King is, which at one point looked as if he might be this generation's Matthew Shepard. However, this generation is different. We don't have to worry about the AIDS Crisis, we don't have to worry about the issues those at the Stonewall Riots or the Compton's Cafeteria Riots had to deal with, Ellen has been out for years now and Matthew Shepard was murdered over 10 years ago. For our youth who are 13 or 14 years old, how are they to connect with any of this? The mainstream community does not have our interests at the heart of their movement and then they complain about the complacency of youth when we do not have their agenda at the top of our list. Why would a 15-year-old gay teenager care about gay marriage when he is being harassed in the locker room, in the hallways and doesn't have anyone to talk to? Why would a trans youth care about the "gay and lesbian" mainstream movement when zie can't even use the bathroom at school? The mainstream movement needs to be working to support safe school legislation and hate crimes legislation so that our youth are even around and active members of the queer community before we can start worrying about "marriage equality" a notion that those at Stonewall and Compton's Cafeteria would have laughed at. Just because the older generation has evolved enough that marriage equality is their last stepping stone, doesn't mean the rest of the community is at the same place.

Add your comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Syndicate content Syndicate content
icon_win10000.jpg

Bookmark and Share

Campus Pride Blog

The Campus Pride Blog: Campus Q&A provides a forum to ask questions and get answers. Now you can hear perspectives, issues, news and events from LGBT & Ally student leaders at colleges and universities across the United States.

CP_blog_web_ad.jpg
FIND_icon.jpg
Lead With Pride: Join Campus Pride!

CP_twitter.jpg
Campus Pride on Facebook
Campus Pride on MySpace
CP_shoutB_0.jpg

Campus Q&A is moderated by LGBT and ally student leaders from across the United States.

Blogger Login